"When the cancer on the mountain whistles": meaning, a synonym and examples of the use of phraseology

If a person is asked to do something that he does not want or can not do physically, the question: "When will it all happen?" - he can answer: "When the cancer on the mountain whistles." Today we will analyze the meaning of the expression.

Careful analysis of the image of cancer

When a person uses "cancer", "mountain" and "whistle" in one sentence, he expresses in this way the attitude to a certain event, which, in his opinion, is unlikely - as they usually say when they want to smooth the corners. In fact, the likelihood that the cancer will climb the mountain, put the claw in your mouth and whistle to the full power of the lungs is not that small, such an opportunity is not even theoretically possible. In other words, if you ask anyone: "And when the cancer on the mountain whistles?" - the answer is: "Never!" And this is closest to the meaning of the proverb or phraseology. Cancer can not whistle for three reasons:

1. He does not have lungs.
2. He has no fingers to make the whistle loud, disturbing the minds, hearts and ears.
3. Due to anatomical features, the cancer does not climb the mountain.

And if someone asks in all seriousness: "And when the cancer on the mountain whistles?" - Look at him puzzled.

Zoological data say: some cancers can make sounds similar to whistles, but such an action occurs, as a rule, in the water, and animals use for this purpose their claws. In a stable expression, cancer complicates the task to the impossibility. Yes, and in addition, it is not a special kind of crayfish, but a river one. It is clear that the latter can not do any such tricks and in general the essence is simple, if not primitive, without special signs of a creative or extraordinary nature.

Expressive tone and example

In a decent society - on a social event - a person will not be able to use the expression "when the cancer on the mountain whistles", it is too rude and prostrate. But the situation changes when two friends talk about football, and one of the other asks:

- When Russia will beat Brazil with a score of 5: 0?

- Phraseology "cancer on the mountain whistles" you know? That's when the arthropod can whistle to the full power of his lungs, which he does not have, and then wait for the victory of our team over Brazil.

There was even such a joke: that Russia should become the world champion in football, the Brazilians should become the world hockey champion. Since then, the balance of power in world football has changed somewhat, now the tone is set by the Germans and the Spaniards, but the joke is still relevant.

Synonym

It would seem that the whistle of cancer and rain are phenomena that have a different degree of probability. Whistling of the animal is impossible in principle, and rain is likely on any day of the week. But the expression about cancer, which we are closely examining, and the phraseology "after the rain on Thursday" are synonyms.

If we do not know exactly where the expression about cancer came from, then there is certainty with the rain on Thursday. It is known that the Slavs were not always Christians, before worshiping God they worshiped a host of gods. Thursday was Perun's day. The supreme god of the ancient Slavs sent prayers that he would give the earth a rain. It is not difficult to understand that God, since he is very busy, has not heard people very often. Paganism became a relic and a history, and the proverb remained to describe unrealistic hopes. This is the history of phraseology "after the rain on Thursday".

An example of Russian phraseology from Hollywood

It's about the 1996 comedy "Lucky Gilmore." The main character had a dream - to become a hockey player, but since he could not really skate, the cherished desire to come true was not to be. But he had a stunning blow force. And then the misfortune happened - the grandmother's house is sold for debts. Happy, who worked then did not work, he needed a stable income, and he discovered golf.

Further known is the opposition of good and evil. Happy has a sworn enemy. And before the final battle, Happy tells the villain that this battle will win him, and the enemy answers him: "Yeah, after the rain on Thursday." Of course, good conquered evil. Happy has joined the ranks of the "Cinderella". Everything was wonderful. Such films have no intrigue, the most important thing is the process of ascent to the top. It is he who attracts the audience and the humor of Adam Sandler.

So, we considered the phraseology "when the cancer on the mountain whistles." No one doubts the meaning of it any more and does not raise questions. In addition, if someone does not like this expression, then you can use its synonym, which was discussed above. In our time, the main thing is that a person has a choice. Perhaps the reader will propose something third, but this is his business.